Approval rates vary

Letter to the Editor - The Australian
30 October 2003

Dear Sir/Madam

There is nothing new in Sophie Morris' article Visas for 9 in 10 refugees (29 October) that there were high approval rates for unauthorised boat arrivals from late 1999 to mid 2001.

These approval rates reflect the large numbers of Iraqis and Afghans arriving at that time, and the circumstances in those countries.

Refugee decisions are taken on their merits, on a case-by-case using the definition of a refugee set out in the Refugees Convention.

Approval rates vary over time depending on caseloads and circumstances. For example, half of the 1500 people intercepted in late 2001 en route to Australia and processed offshore were found not to be refugees.

Between July 1999 and June 2001, Australia received 10 boats with over 200 passengers, where not one was owed protection by Australia.

Sophie is correct in indicating that unauthorised arrivals found to have engaged Australia's protection are granted Temporary Protection Visas. These people are immediately released from detention.

Temporary Protection visa arrangements reflect that under the international framework of protection, the preferred durable solution for most refugees is that they be given interim protection in a safe country until they are able to return to their homeland in safety and dignity.

The arrangements also ensure that refugees are protected, while preserving scarce permanent humanitarian program places wherever possible to resettle refugees and others from overseas who are in greatest need of a new home.

Stewart Foster
Director
Public Affairs
DIMIA